View of a mountain range - Yosemite National Park - and grey-pinkish-blue sky with clouds.
  • About
  • Practice Areas
  • FAQs
  • Appointments
  • Fees
  • Resources

  • Emotion
  • Mindfulness
  • Therapy & Technology
  • Talks & Publications


  • Blog

How to find a therapist



TL;DR



• Choosing a therapist is a bit like dating: it requires effort, time, patience and may involve needing to “kiss” a few frogs before finding the right match

• Your best friend’s therapist may not be the therapist that’s best for you

• It’s important to interview multiple therapists

• During the first meeting you should ask the therapist some questions – it’s not just an ‘intake’ for you but, in a way, also for the therapist

• The ‘fit’ between you and the therapist is essential – it may take some effort to figure out what a good fit is for you

• Last but not least: if you are in acute distress, and need immediate help, the advice in this post may not apply to you. In such situations a clinic may be the best option, where you may find someone faster and it may be easier to switch therapists if the first person is not a good fit




Obviously, I am not suggesting you should be dating your therapist. (Among other ‘issues’, that would also constitute a major ethical violation on the part of the therapist!) What I mean is that just as you would not expect to meet your soulmate on the first random blind date, or a Tinder ‘swipe right’ situation, it’s unlikely that the first therapist you interview will be the best fit. Could it happen? Sure. But I’m not sure how likely it is.

So - how is finding a therapist like dating? It takes time, effort, patience and it may involve some frogs. But it’s also not rocket science so please read on to get a few, hopefully helpful, hints.

First of all, let’s just acknowledge one thing: for most of us, looking for a therapist is a pain in the neck. First, you have to do a lot of searching to find the potential candidates. In some cases, you get recommendations for specific people but be careful with that. (More on this below.) Then you have to filter the initial list, call, text or email, wait for the response, which may never come, or be told the practice is full, then go through the arduous scheduling process and in some cases also deal with your insurance company’s bureaucracy. And all of this can easily take several months. Then you finally meet the therapist but maybe you’re not sure you like them or feel comfortable with them. Then you may have a period of questioning and self-doubt, while the co-pays and deductible accumulate, etc. etc. etc. If you’ve been through the drill, you know what I am talking about.

And at the same time a ‘good fit’ is critical for therapy. This has been demonstrated over and over in empirical studies of therapy effectiveness, plus, of course, it makes sense. How could you share your innermost secrets, often vulnerabilities, fears you may be ashamed of or fragile dreams you may worry are unachievable, with someone you don’t feel comfortable with?

Now, that said, there might be specific circumstances where the fit is less important. For example, if you have a specific fear or phobia of a particular object or situation, which are often treatable with fixed, short-term treatments, the fit may be less important. This situation is somewhat analogous to something like an 8 week course of physical therapy for an injury. Sure, it’s obviously better if you like the provider, no matter what the issue, but if someone is following an established, evidence-based procedure and you see them once a week for 8 weeks they can still administer an effective treatment and the relationship matters less. However, I don’t think this scenario represents the majority of reasons why we seek therapy.

So – how can we expedite the process of finding a therapist and, most importantly, how can we tell whether it’s a ‘good fit’ – obviously a rather vague concept?

I think it’s important to approach the process with a realistic set of expectations. This will help avoid frustration and disappointment. Per above, it’s typically not easy and in fact it can be a lengthy and at times frustrating process. I am not saying this to be discouraging but rather to acknowledge the reality of the endeavor so that we are not disappointed when we don’t immediately find the right person.

Again, think of the dating analogy. Sure, you might be in the very small minority of people who go on a first date, meet the love of their life and live happily ever after. But this is not the norm. You need to meet some number of people to not only find the right person but, equally importantly, to figure out what you are looking for, what works for you. It’s the same with finding a therapist. So in my mind it’s very important to interview multiple therapists. But – first you have to find the candidates.

Finding potential therapists to interview

First, we have to find some therapists and then we have to filter the initial list. There are a number of ways to find therapists and not all of them are equally effective. One option is to see if your workplace can provide some names. This is often the case in academic institutions and some workplaces (e.g., Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs)). These can be helpful since EAPs etc. may already have a list of therapists they work with. In some cases the EAP contact person may even know some of these therapists and can facilitate the initial contact. Another option is to ask your primary provider to see if they can recommend someone. And of course, you can ask friends for recommendations. All of these have the benefit that you may find someone faster but you sacrifice some degree of privacy. (Hopefully this is not an issue these days, when therapy has been significantly de-stigmatized and in some places you are considered odd if you are not in therapy. Nevertheless, it may be a concern and that’s ok.)

A word of caution about personal recommendations of the type “I am seeing an amazing therapist and I know you will love them!” or “This therapist helped me with xyz and I know they can help you too!” First of all, just because your best friend liked someone doesn’t mean you will. It’s possible, sure, so worth giving it try. But a problem with this is that we may then feel pressure to like the person, even when it’s not a good fit, and that may cause us to stay with a therapist that may not be the best match for us. Second, different therapists have different strengths, levels of expertise and may be terrific at helping with problem x but not so great with problem y. So, again, your mileage may vary.

Another approach is to pour yourself a stiff drink and attempt to contact your insurance company. Minimally the insurance company should provide you with a list of therapists in their network. This is a starting point but these lists are often out of date (e.g., therapist no longer in network, no longer practicing, has been dead for several decades, etc.). In some cases the insurance company may have a specific person that will actually help you find a therapist and potentially facilitate the process but, in my experience, this is less common.

The most common approach these days is to look on-line. Many, perhaps most, therapists have some type of an on-line presence. This ranges from a profile on web sites such as Psychology Today, increasingly the therapist’s own web site, and often some presence on social media which might also include presentations, blogs, video clips, etc. The more you can find out about the therapist before you reach out, the better, obviously. You can read what they say about themselves, what training they have, what is their level of expertise in general and in specific areas (e.g., working with clients with specific demographic characteristics or having expertise in specific treatment approaches or for particular ‘issues’). If the therapist has a blog, or some videos of lectures or presentations, those will provide you with important information about their general ‘style’. And of course, logistical factors such as whether they meet in person or virtually only, whether they offer walking therapy, their location, etc.

What should you filter for during this initial search?

First of all, don’t be afraid to acknowledge your demographic, age or any other specific therapist characteristic preferences you may have and seek someone who matches them. And these days, with politics increasingly entering our lives – and our therapy rooms - it’s perfectly fine to ask the therapist about their political beliefs. Not every therapist would agree with this but that’s what I’ve come to believe. Now, that said, the therapist may not want to disclose some information and that’s also fine. More data for you when you are making the decision whom to see.

Second, pay attention to your reactions as you read the therapist’s profile. Are you feeling a sense of some degree of connection already? Are you curious to find out more about the therapist? Is the profile similar to all other therapy profiles or does something stand out that appeals to you? And, of course, note any negative reactions you may experience.

Finally, if you have had prior experience with therapy, you may already know what you like and need and vice versa. Do you need more or less structure? Do you like ‘homeworks’ or do homeworks feel like pressure and yet another chore? How often do you want to meet? And, perhaps most importantly, are you looking to change something or are you looking more for support in your current situation. This can be a difficult question to answer, and, in fact, answering it is a legitimate ‘treatment goal’ early on in therapy - and an important one.

OK. So now hopefully you have a short list of candidate therapists and are ready for the next step: interviewing multiple therapists before deciding whom to see.

Interviewing multiple therapists

I personally believe that this is essential and has at least three benefits. The first two are analogous to the dating process: you have a better chance of finding the right person and, perhaps more importantly, it gives you a chance to understand what is important to you. Do you want the therapist to talk more or less? To ask a lot of direct questions or to listen more? To give specific feedback or not? To suggest ‘homework’ outside of the session? To suggest books, including self-help books and research articles? Do you prefer structured sessions (e.g., a check-in at the beginning to see what progress has been made, a reflection at the end to see how useful (or not) the session was) or a more free-form format?

It's a good idea to put together a list of questions you want to ask. Starting with the simple ones (e.g., what type of therapy do you practice, how long have you been practicing, what does a typical session look like, what is your experience with ‘clients like me’, issues such as xyz, etc.) but maybe some more difficult ones (e.g., do you think you can help me? How long will it take for me to get better? Is your approach to condition xyz effective, evidence-based?). In other words, don’t be afraid to ask any reasonable question, where ‘reasonable’ includes respecting the therapist’s privacy.

And of course, be prepared to tell the therapist why you seek therapy, and why now. Some therapists also like to find out about previous therapy, to see what has been helpful and what may not have been helpful.

And now you are ready to begin the interviewing process and finding out whether a particular therapist is a ‘good fit’.

Is it a good fit?

Determining whether a therapist candidate is a good fit begins with the first contact, continues with the scheduling process, the initial brief, free call, which some therapists offer, and the first session. Or first few sessions. Pay attention to all of these stages and monitor your reactions to the following:

Is it easy to contact the therapist? Do they respond in a timely manner? Do they sound friendly or more formal over the phone, email – and what type of a tone do you prefer? How is the scheduling process – relatively easy or requiring many iterations? What is the new client paperwork like? If there is an intake form, does it ask questions you find helpful? Intrusive? Upsetting? If payments are discussed, do you feel comfortable with the manner in which they are discussed? Are you ok with the cancellation policy, if there is one?

If the therapist offers a free initial consultation, I would suggest you take advantage of this. In most cases this may be a brief call or a brief initial meeting. Some therapists may offer a first free session but I am not sure how frequent that is. Whatever the first free contact the therapist may offer it’s a good idea to take advantage of this because you may be able to eliminate some candidates right away, if it ‘doesn’t feel right’.

Let’s assume you have jumped through all these hoops and you have an initial session scheduled. This is your chance to interview the therapist and ask all of the questions you have prepared. Of course, the therapist will also be asking you questions about what brings you to therapy and may want to ask you more detailed questions about your background, family, previous therapy etc.

Some things you want to note: Does the therapist invite you to ask questions or do you feel you have to ‘fight for airtime’? How does the therapist respond to your questions – in depth? authentically? Do you feel satisfied with the responses and, if not, do you feel comfortable asking for clarifications?

When you say that you are interviewing multiple therapists, and I do think it’s a good idea to say this upfront, how does the therapist react? Are they ok with it? Do they encourage this? I believe that a response to this question can tell you something important about the therapist: if they respond in an understanding, even encouraging way, that’s a good sign. If they react negatively, well…. that’s an important data point. Now, let’s just be clear about one thing. I think it’s natural for a therapist to have a small inside thought “What do you mean interviewing multiple therapists? Can’t you see that I am the greatest therapist since sliced bread?” We are, after all, human (though that may be changing soon). But that thought should be small and definitely an inside thought. Any pressure from a therapist at this point is a very negative sign.

So during the session you should monitor how you are feeling, how your feelings change during the session, if they do: Are you feeling more or less comfortable? Do you feel the therapist is genuinely interested in you? Do you feel they are asking appropriate questions? As the session goes on, do you feel you want to meet again? Or do you need to think about it? Or, do you want to leave before the session is over?

Note moments of connection as well as disconnects. Here is an example of a disconnect I experienced with my very first therapist. I was running late, had trouble finding a parking spot, and when I eventually found one, in my haste, I put my last quarter in the wrong parking meter. (This was pre-parking apps.) At that point I just had to laugh because the whole thing was so absurd. So – when I met the therapist, and as I was explaining why I was running late, I recounted the story while laughing. She did not crack a smile during the entire time and her very somber-tone response was: “Was this very upsetting to you?” Uhm, well, no, since I was clearly amused. This is what I mean by a disconnect. Needless to say, this turned out not to be a good fit. And the specific lessons here? First, notice the therapist’s (mis)attunement with your emotions during a session and second, if humor is important to you, you will likely do better with a therapist who has a sense of humor and is able to laugh, with you!, at the absurdities of life.

After the session you should ask yourself: How do you feel? Better than before? Less or more anxious (assuming you felt some level of stress prior to the session)? Hopeful that the therapist may help? Looking forward to seeing them again? Neutral? Or dreading the prospect? And, just as in dating, how do you feel about yourself during, and after, the session?

It’s really important to tune in to your feelings - and to trust them. A problem here is that when we are in distress we may experience self-doubt. This may take the form of thoughts such as: “I wasn’t crazy about this therapist but I’m not feeling great, it’s probably just me” or “I actually feel worse after the session but that’s probably normal when talking about difficult topics”. Pay a lot of attention to these types of thoughts. While it’s of course true that bringing up painful topics can be distressing it definitely should not be the norm to feel worse after a session. Importantly, it’s fine to tell a therapist that talking about xyz is making you feel worse – and see how they respond. In general, you should feel better, or at least somewhat hopeful that you will be feeling better, after the session.

It may take more than one session to see if it’s a good fit. I tell potential new clients to ‘give it 2 or 3 times’. If it’s working, great. If not, we can either try and understand why the sessions aren’t helpful or I can help the client find another therapist.

I hope that some of this was helpful and invite you to read a related post, coming soon: When and how to leave a therapist.